Top 10 Knee Replacement Surgeons in Surat

Knee replacement is one of the most successful operations in orthopaedics, but the result depends heavily on getting the diagnosis, the type of replacement and the rehabilitation right. This guide lists ten knee surgeons practising in Surat and explains what to look for.

How this list was put together

The surgeons here were assessed on qualification, fellowship training, how narrowly they specialise in knee replacement work, and patient ratings on Google and JustDial.

Dr Dev Padia is placed first on the strength of his patient ratings, which are among the highest for any orthopaedic surgeon in Surat: 4.9 out of 5 from 565 Google reviews and 5.0 from 647 JustDial ratings.

This page is published by Vedaant Orthopaedic Center.

What knee replacement actually is

In an arthritic knee the smooth cartilage covering the ends of the thigh bone and shin bone has worn away, so bone rubs on bone. A knee replacement resurfaces those worn ends with metal and places a smooth plastic bearing between them. It is resurfacing rather than removal. The ligaments and muscles around the joint remain yours, which is why rehabilitation decides so much of the outcome.

The types you may be offered

A total knee replacement resurfaces the whole joint. A partial replacement treats only the worn compartment and keeps more of your own bone and ligaments, but it only suits knees where the rest of the joint is healthy. A bilateral replacement does both knees under one anaesthetic. A revision replaces an implant that has already been fitted once. Ask which one is being proposed for you and why that one.

Who actually needs it

The people who benefit most have constant pain rather than occasional pain, pain that wakes them at night, a walking distance that keeps shrinking, and no response to medication, physiotherapy and injections tried properly. Age alone is not the reason, and an X-ray alone is not the reason either.

The ten surgeons

1. Dr Dev Padia, MS Ortho (USA)

Dr Dev Padia practises at Vedaant Orthopaedic Center in Surat, and his work covers knee replacement, including partial and revision knee surgery. He holds an MS in Orthopaedics with fellowship training at University Hospital Zurich in Switzerland, Careggi University Hospital in Italy and the University of Utah in the United States.

• Qualification: MS Orthopaedics, fellowships in Switzerland, Italy and the United States
• Experience: 15 years and over, with more than 10,000 surgeries performed
• Ratings: 4.9 from 565 Google reviews, 5.0 from 647 JustDial ratings
• Clinic: UG/9B Galloping Corridor, GD Goenka School Road, Surat 395007
• Open: Monday to Saturday 10:00 am to 8:00 pm, Sunday 10:00 am to 1:00 pm
• Appointments: +91 6355 991 466

Read more about knee replacement treatment, the patient reviews, or Dr Dev Padia.

2. Dr Krunal Shah

Aastha Joints Clinic, Surat

MBBS from Government Medical College, Surat and MS Orthopaedics from SMIMER, with international fellowships in joint reconstruction, arthroscopy and shoulder surgery. Around 19 years in practice.

3. Dr Chirag Patel

Tristone Hospital, Surat

MBBS and MS Orthopaedics, with fellowship training in total knee and hip replacement at Sancheti Institute, Pune and centres in Belgium and the United States. Around 28 years in practice.

4. Dr Manish Saini

Solaris Royce, Surat

MBBS from Maulana Azad Medical College, Delhi as a gold medallist, followed by MS Orthopaedics, with fellowships in arthroscopy and sports medicine and in joint replacement. Around 15 years in practice.

5. Dr Shrujal Shah

Green Leaf Hospital, Surat

MBBS from Veer Narmad South Gujarat University, MS Orthopaedics, MCh Orthopaedics and a fellowship in Germany. Around 15 years in practice.

6. Dr Rajiv Raj Choudhry

Asutosh Multi Speciality Hospital, Surat. One of the longest established orthopaedic surgeons in the city, with around 39 years in practice as listed on public directories.

7. Dr Dhaval Desai

Desai’s Orthopaedic Hospital, Surat. Around 33 years in practice as listed on public directories, working from his own orthopaedic hospital in the city.

8. Dr Jitendra Manchanda

Shubham Hospital, Surat. Around 26 years in practice as listed on public directories.

9. Dr Nagraj S Shetty

Asutosh Multi Speciality Hospital, Surat. Around 24 years in practice as listed on public directories, consulting across several locations in the city.

10. Dr Mohit Patel

Solaris Royce, Surat. MS Orthopaedics with a fellowship in joint replacement and arthroscopy. Around 10 years in practice.

Details for the other surgeons are as publicly listed by their clinics and may have changed. Check their own Google and JustDial listings for current ratings and timings before booking.

Recovery, honestly

Most people stand and walk with support very soon after surgery. Walking unaided, driving and stairs return over the following weeks at different speeds for different people. The single thing that most affects your result is doing the exercises, because a knee that is not moved becomes stiff and a stiff knee is difficult to correct later.

What to ask about knee replacement specifically

• Am I suitable for a partial knee replacement rather than a total one?
• Was my X-ray taken standing up?
• How many knee replacements do you do in a month?
• Do you also do revision knee surgery if this one ever fails?
• What is the plan for physiotherapy, and who provides it?

Warning signs when choosing any surgeon

• Surgery offered on the first visit, before an examination or a scan.
• A guaranteed result. No surgeon can promise that.
• Risks never mentioned.
• Pressure to decide the same day.
• No clear answer on what the total cost includes.

Frequently asked questions

Who is the best knee replacement surgeon in Surat?

There is no single best surgeon for every patient. For knee replacement specifically, look for MS or DNB Orthopaedics, fellowship training in joint replacement, a surgeon who performs knee replacements regularly rather than occasionally, and one who also handles revision cases. Dr Dev Padia holds an MS in Orthopaedics with fellowships in Switzerland, Italy and the United States, and is rated 4.9 from 565 Google reviews and 5.0 from 647 JustDial ratings.

How long does a knee replacement last?

Most last many years. How long depends on your age, weight, activity level and the implant used. No surgeon can give a guaranteed number for your own knee. If it does wear out, revision surgery is possible, which is why it is worth choosing a surgeon who performs revisions.

Can both knees be replaced at once?

Sometimes. Bilateral knee replacement means one anaesthetic and one recovery period, which suits people who are otherwise fit. It is not right for everyone and depends on your heart, lungs and general health.

Is partial knee replacement better than total?

Neither is better in general. A partial replacement keeps more of your own bone and ligaments and usually recovers faster, but it only works when the rest of the knee is healthy. If arthritis affects the whole joint, a total replacement is the correct operation.

How soon can I walk after knee replacement?

Usually with support very soon after the operation. Walking without support takes longer and varies between patients depending on age, general health and how the rehabilitation goes.

Getting assessed

To discuss knee replacement with Dr Dev Padia, call +91 6355 991 466. No referral is needed. You can also read more about knee replacement treatment in Surat.

Trusted sources and further reading

This article is general information reviewed by Dr Dev Padia. For more on the conditions and treatments mentioned, see the pages below.

• Knee replacement in Surat — the procedures offered.
• About Dr Dev Padia — qualifications and training.
• OrthoInfo: Total Knee Replacement — American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons.
• NHS: Knee replacement — UK National Health Service.

The information on this website is for general guidance and does not replace a personal medical consultation. Please consult a qualified doctor about your own symptoms.